"She crossed her arms over her chest, looked right into Finn's blue-bird eyes, and told him it was just hard to find the time these days.
"Tell me about it," he said.
That's what broke her." - Tell the Wolves I'm Home by Carol Rifka Brunt
"Tell me about it," he said.
That's what broke her." - Tell the Wolves I'm Home by Carol Rifka Brunt
This book, this BOOK, THIS BOOK!
I couldn't put it down.
I couldn't put it down.
It's the 80s. June Elbus is 14, trying to get along with her older sister Greta, and her uncle is painting their portrait.
June thinks she's in love with him.
He also happens to be dying of AIDS.
Junie's love for her uncle Finn is at once fascinating and heartbreaking. From the first interaction we read about, we know that their relationship is a special one: it transcends the typical familial relationship into something more like a true friendship, in spite of June's clouded romantic feelings. Yes, she knows it's wrong to feel that way about her uncle, but she can't help it. He is magical: an artist, living in an apartment in New York City, removed from the suburban Westchester June and her family inhabit. Finn smokes, paints, takes June around to different places in the city... it's easy to understand how a girl could fall for him.
It isn't until his death that she finds out the secret: he had a boyfriend.
Now this wasn't exactly a surprise to me as a reader (and June did know he was gay), considering the little bits the author had sprinkled in the book up until this point, but June's family (and Finn himself) does a good job of hiding it from the kids. Why, well, at first I wasn't sure. But as the story develops and we get to see into the strained relationship between Finn and his sister (June's mother), we begin to see that sometimes those who know us best can still misunderstand - or flat out refuse to comprehend - the decisions we make.
After Finn's death, his boyfriend Toby contacts June, unbeknownst to her family. Thus begins the real story: June comes to know who Finn really was, and to people outside of her circle. She learns the truth about the man she only saw through a rose-coloured lens; she starts to see that he was so much more than just her uncle and object of her affection.
Her relationship with Toby is really something. At first, her perception of him is clouded by the labels her family threw his way, with the largest one being that he's the man responsible for Finn's death. Well, not quite... but I'll leave that to you to discover. As months and secret meetings come and go, June begins to feel a kinship with Toby and realizes that in sharing Finn with him, she is able to grow something new from the death that occurred.
Of course, while all of this is happening, we have June's relationship with Greta to look at. The portrait of the two girls, titled 'Tell The Wolves I'm Home,' ends up being appraised and with such great value, is set in a safety deposit box in a bank in the city. Both girls commit small acts of vandalism on the painting (sounds more sinister than it is) and it's almost as if they communicate with each other through these. While I grew annoyed with Greta's brushing off of June so often, as the older sister who never seems to have time to just be a child (and who develops a bit of a drinking problem at the tender age of 16!), as things progress there are little moments where you can see the love the girls have for each other. They're quite sweet and actually quite realistic to what I think sisters go through.
The poignancy of the writing really got to me. I felt for June. I alternately cursed and cried for Greta. But the author's way of examining loss and heartache through the eyes of these young women stirred something in me, that sense of emptiness I too-often feel when I have that ache of wanting to talk with my mother: "[W]hat I really wanted to do was cry. Not only because Finn had never told me about this guy, but because there was no way to ask him about it. And until then I don't think I really understood the meaning of gone."
Yes, it's a cliché (and a Joni Mitchell line that Janet Jackson ripped off) that you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone. But it's true. I recently went away for a few days with my aunt and it was only when we were chatting about my mom's history and what she was like when I was a kid that I realised that I have so many questions that only she would have been able to answer. I even tried asking my dad, but he doesn't remember... it really was a lifetime ago. And there isn't anything you can do to fill up that void, it's just kind of... there. I try to piece together a picture as best I can with the people who knew her and the memories I still hold on to, but, well, it isn't the same. It's mostly speculation. So is this blog.
In taking my aunt around London at the beginning of her visit, I saw more and more of my mom (this aunt is sort of related to me by marriage - so I don't mean biologically). The more I walk around this fair city, the more I show it to other people and allow them to delve into the nooks and crannies I have so lovingly discovered, the more I wish to share it with my mom. I've said before that she would have loved it here, and I still think so. Readers, I've gone through a massive transition in my life over the last few months - which may or may not be revealed at some point - and now that I'm on the other side of things, well, everything reminds me of her. The passage below exemplifies this:
I understood how just about anything in the world could remind you of Finn. Trains, or New York City, or plants, or books, or soft sweet black-and-white cookies, or some guy in Central Park playing a polka on the harmonica and the violin at the same time. Things you'd never even seen with Finn could remind you of him, because he was the one person you'd want to show. "Look at that," you'd want to say, because you knew he would find a way to think it was wonderful. To make you feel like the most observant person in the world for spotting it.
That is so true. I can't think of someone I want to share my new life with more than her - and yes I know that perhaps somewhere out there she is watching, but it just ain't the same. I do know, however, that she is still very present in myself and my sister, and I guess all we can do is just allow that to come through in us and hope that it diminishes the ache - and brings forth a smile.
June thinks she's in love with him.
He also happens to be dying of AIDS.
Junie's love for her uncle Finn is at once fascinating and heartbreaking. From the first interaction we read about, we know that their relationship is a special one: it transcends the typical familial relationship into something more like a true friendship, in spite of June's clouded romantic feelings. Yes, she knows it's wrong to feel that way about her uncle, but she can't help it. He is magical: an artist, living in an apartment in New York City, removed from the suburban Westchester June and her family inhabit. Finn smokes, paints, takes June around to different places in the city... it's easy to understand how a girl could fall for him.
It isn't until his death that she finds out the secret: he had a boyfriend.
Now this wasn't exactly a surprise to me as a reader (and June did know he was gay), considering the little bits the author had sprinkled in the book up until this point, but June's family (and Finn himself) does a good job of hiding it from the kids. Why, well, at first I wasn't sure. But as the story develops and we get to see into the strained relationship between Finn and his sister (June's mother), we begin to see that sometimes those who know us best can still misunderstand - or flat out refuse to comprehend - the decisions we make.
After Finn's death, his boyfriend Toby contacts June, unbeknownst to her family. Thus begins the real story: June comes to know who Finn really was, and to people outside of her circle. She learns the truth about the man she only saw through a rose-coloured lens; she starts to see that he was so much more than just her uncle and object of her affection.
Her relationship with Toby is really something. At first, her perception of him is clouded by the labels her family threw his way, with the largest one being that he's the man responsible for Finn's death. Well, not quite... but I'll leave that to you to discover. As months and secret meetings come and go, June begins to feel a kinship with Toby and realizes that in sharing Finn with him, she is able to grow something new from the death that occurred.
Of course, while all of this is happening, we have June's relationship with Greta to look at. The portrait of the two girls, titled 'Tell The Wolves I'm Home,' ends up being appraised and with such great value, is set in a safety deposit box in a bank in the city. Both girls commit small acts of vandalism on the painting (sounds more sinister than it is) and it's almost as if they communicate with each other through these. While I grew annoyed with Greta's brushing off of June so often, as the older sister who never seems to have time to just be a child (and who develops a bit of a drinking problem at the tender age of 16!), as things progress there are little moments where you can see the love the girls have for each other. They're quite sweet and actually quite realistic to what I think sisters go through.
The poignancy of the writing really got to me. I felt for June. I alternately cursed and cried for Greta. But the author's way of examining loss and heartache through the eyes of these young women stirred something in me, that sense of emptiness I too-often feel when I have that ache of wanting to talk with my mother: "[W]hat I really wanted to do was cry. Not only because Finn had never told me about this guy, but because there was no way to ask him about it. And until then I don't think I really understood the meaning of gone."
Yes, it's a cliché (and a Joni Mitchell line that Janet Jackson ripped off) that you don't know what you've got 'til it's gone. But it's true. I recently went away for a few days with my aunt and it was only when we were chatting about my mom's history and what she was like when I was a kid that I realised that I have so many questions that only she would have been able to answer. I even tried asking my dad, but he doesn't remember... it really was a lifetime ago. And there isn't anything you can do to fill up that void, it's just kind of... there. I try to piece together a picture as best I can with the people who knew her and the memories I still hold on to, but, well, it isn't the same. It's mostly speculation. So is this blog.
In taking my aunt around London at the beginning of her visit, I saw more and more of my mom (this aunt is sort of related to me by marriage - so I don't mean biologically). The more I walk around this fair city, the more I show it to other people and allow them to delve into the nooks and crannies I have so lovingly discovered, the more I wish to share it with my mom. I've said before that she would have loved it here, and I still think so. Readers, I've gone through a massive transition in my life over the last few months - which may or may not be revealed at some point - and now that I'm on the other side of things, well, everything reminds me of her. The passage below exemplifies this:
I understood how just about anything in the world could remind you of Finn. Trains, or New York City, or plants, or books, or soft sweet black-and-white cookies, or some guy in Central Park playing a polka on the harmonica and the violin at the same time. Things you'd never even seen with Finn could remind you of him, because he was the one person you'd want to show. "Look at that," you'd want to say, because you knew he would find a way to think it was wonderful. To make you feel like the most observant person in the world for spotting it.
That is so true. I can't think of someone I want to share my new life with more than her - and yes I know that perhaps somewhere out there she is watching, but it just ain't the same. I do know, however, that she is still very present in myself and my sister, and I guess all we can do is just allow that to come through in us and hope that it diminishes the ache - and brings forth a smile.
"Here," I said, passing one to Greta.
"You know, the smoking. It surprised me."
"Just something I picked up," I said, grinning, and I realized that Toby was shining through me so strongly then that for a moment I was almost completely invisible.